Video: A Religiously Neutral Method for Judging Miracles

Miracles seem to be a special pleading problem for Christians. The Bible claims many miracles that we often take for granted. But we turn into Richard Dawkins when other religions claim miracles. David Hume made the same complaint in his “Of Miracles” essay. What if I said Christians can meet this challenge? Enter John Douglas. Douglas was an Anglican bishop who responded to Hume’s essay. In response, Douglas offered religiously neutral criteria to filter out unverifiable miracle claims. So what were the criteria? Douglas said we can rationally doubt a miracle when…

  1. It is first reported long after the alleged miracle occurred.
  2. It is first reported far away from where the alleged miracle happened.
  3. If the report of it could have been approved without closer examination.

Here I examine what miracle claims fail Douglas’ test. Does the resurrection pass? What about miracles in other religions?

Liked it? Take a second to support Erik Manning on Patreon!
Is Jesus Alive?